Robert Jeffreys: Man At The Window


Robert Cardilini is another sad cop, sunk into apathy and drunkenness since the death of his wife a year ago. Once he was one of the best, now he’s just a waste of space. So his boss gives him the case of a shooting death at an elite private school with powerful old boys everywhere, and makes it clear that he just has to tick it off as an accident. But Cardilini is still enough of a good cop to see that all the rules of procedure have been broken, and still contrary enough to want to do something about it. It doesn’t help that the school staff makes it clear that he’s an oik who has no idea how things should be done.

Cardilini believes that the shooting was deliberate, and carried out by someone highly-skilled. He has to go round lots of people to investigate, and he’s lucky that he has at least one person in the line of command who wants to do the right thing, and who gives him a little leeway. The solution to the crime is an intriguing one that’s borne in on us gradually. Someone thought the victim deserved to die and that the law wasn’t up to it. We’re left with quite a bit of sympathy for that view.

There’s the law, and then there’s justice, says the blurb. Who gets to decide?

I enjoyed this a lot (memo to the publishers though, there are some horrible proof-reading errors, like calling someone Miss Reynolds in one line and Mrs Reynolds in the next).  Set evocatively in Perth, it’s Robert Jeffreys’ first novel, and said to be the first in a series. I’ll give Cardilini another canter.



2 thoughts on “Robert Jeffreys: Man At The Window

  1. This is beginning to sound too much like real life Gert. In Canada we have an Attorney General who was bullied by the PMO (Prime Minister’s Office) to let some slippery multinational off the hook for their bribery misdeeds. Apparently the company provides a lot of employment (plus probably large political contributions that come in handy for the next election). Then there’s this “bullying” to the extent of sexual assault at one of our most prestigious private schools. When “the school staff makes it clear that he’s an oil” one begins to realize how much this behaviour is imbedded in our society.

  2. Yes, I’m afraid the old boy network is alive and well. And where crimes are concerned, it’s one law for the well-connected and another for everyone else. I just watched “A Very English Scandal” about a politician who was in court because he’d tried to get a homosexual lover killed. In his summing up the judge was eloquent about what a fine man the politician was, what a distinguished record of service etc etc, and what a disgusting degenerate the lover was – he followed that up by saying, “Of course, you can still believe what he (the lover) says”. As if!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s